Thinking about Bullying
United Kingdom · CPD points & talks · Psychologists
Spastick, ugly, fat, weird, knock-kneed. These are some of the descriptions I have heard children give, in explaining why a particular victim deserves to be pranked, taunted, and laughed at.
As a therapist, do I join with my client in laughing along at some of the images he or she finds amusing, or do I confront him or her for what sounds like obvious cruelty towards another child who is struggling to fit in? Somehow it seems easier to work with the victim than the bully. The victim’s self-esteem can be addressed, and s/he can be given space to express his/her own angry and aggressive feelings which may be repressed or disowned. But how to work with the bully? Bearing in mind that a therapist is neither a friend nor a parent, there must be a third way: beginning to think with the child about the meaning of his or her behaviour .
As a particular child regaled me with his ‘cool kid’ persona, he seemed quite invulnerable. He was accepted, had none of the ‘weird kid’ traits, and his association with the ‘main crowd’ exempted him from being the butt of the jokes. Banding together and laughing at the ‘uncool’ kids seemed to augment this sense of belonging. Just the previous week, the same child had been telling me about another situation in which he felt particularly victimised, pushed around and emotionally squashed, and I could sense his rage about the injustices he perceived. So, how far apart are the victim and the bully, really?
Anna Freud wrote about the defence mechanism she called ‘identification with the aggressor’, to explain how people who have been victimised may be at risk of victimising others[i]. Being victimised or bullied places one in a forced position of helplessness relative to someone more powerful, with feelings of rage towards the bully remaining unexpressed. One way of understanding how the victim might bully others in a weaker position involves the mechanism of displacement: anger towards the bully is taken out on an easier target. Identification with the aggressor may be related, but different: the individual wishes to take on the identity of the more powerful individual, so as to disown the unbearably helpless and weak feelings associated with victimhood. All of those awful victim feelings are projected onto the ‘weird kid’, leaving the bully filled with powerful feelings. In addition, the victim’s ‘weirdness’ or ‘ugliness’ seems in the mind of the bully to render him/her deserving; the victim is abominable, quite frankly disgusting, certainly not someone with whom to identify with an empathic imagination.
In her paper on the psychodynamics of bullying, Margot Waddell observes that bullying so often happens in groups, with strength in numbers being at play. She highlights the fear that hovers beneath the surface of the bully’s awareness: afraid of being a target, the bully must stick closely to the ‘main guys’, make smart remarks to retain their approval, and stay as far as possible from the victim position. Waddell writes about how in addition to ganging up on the victim in the external world, there is a ‘ganging up’ going on in the bully’s internal world; the powerful parts of the self ‘ganging up’ on the weaker, more vulnerable parts[ii]. For some children, the vulnerable parts of the self are hated for being weak and helpless. In bullying, these parts are projected onto a child whose characteristics make him or her a ready target, and the bully simultaneously disowns and attacks them.
So, how to work with the bully? A complicated task if he or she is enjoying feelings of invulnerability and unable or unwilling to think about all this. These thoughts and insights about the more vulnerable self are in the realm of Christopher Bollas’ ‘unthought known’[iii]; the child may know about them unconsciously, but hasn’t been able to think about them consciously. If I can bear them in mind, perhaps we can start to talk about the enormous fear of being like the ‘weird kid’, and the child might feel that his or her more vulnerable self is being borne in mind, even held. If a child can have a benign experience in therapy, perhaps vulnerable aspects of the self can be better tolerated, even accepted. I would venture to say that the converse often applies: the victim may have disowned his or her more aggressive parts, and could use the therapy space to experience and express aggression, with the ultimate therapeutic goal of a more integrated self.
[i] Freud, A. (1936). Identification with the aggressor.The ego and the mechanisms of defence, 117-131.
[ii] Waddell, M. (2007). Grouping or ganging: The psychodynamics of bullying.British Journal of Psychotherapy,23(2), 189-204.
[iii] Bollas, C. (1989).The shadow of the object: Psychoanalysis of the unthought known. Columbia University Press.
Calabash · South AfricaCalabash Articles · South AfricaCalabash Partners · South AfricaCalabash Contributors · South AfricaCalabash Speakers · South AfricaCalabash Talks · South AfricaCalabash Sign up · South AfricaCalabash Sign in · South AfricaNeuro CPD talks · South AfricaMood Disorders CPD talks · South AfricaPersonality CPD talks · South AfricaArticle · Who's afraid of getting into trouble? · South AfricaArticle · Why home treatment for dizziness is not a good idea · South AfricaArticle · Relationships with parents · South AfricaSports Psychology CPD talks · South AfricaFairy Tales CPD talks · South AfricaRelationships CPD talks · South AfricaTalk · Promotion of Access to Information Act (PAIA): What health care professionals need to know · South AfricaTalk · Emotionally dysregulated clients: Supporting families - 1. The distress cycle · South AfricaTalk · The Schizoid Problem · South AfricaAbout Calabash · South AfricaUploading a Talk · South AfricaFrequently Asked Questions · South AfricaCalabash · AustraliaCalabash Articles · AustraliaCalabash Partners · AustraliaCalabash Contributors · AustraliaCalabash Speakers · AustraliaCalabash Talks · AustraliaCalabash Sign up · AustraliaCalabash Sign in · AustraliaPersonality CPD talks · AustraliaCognitive Behavioural Therapy CPD talks · AustraliaMood Disorders CPD talks · AustraliaArticle · On Becoming a Play Therapist · AustraliaArticle · Facebook Ads for Health Care Professionals · AustraliaArticle · Tips to ensure neuroplastic changes in therapy · AustraliaSleep CPD talks · Australia CPD talks · AustraliaDreams CPD talks · AustraliaTalk · The Origins of Mentalising & Implications for Attachment, Personality & Psychotherapy - Part 3 · AustraliaTalk · CBT with Children and Adolescents: Generalized Anxiety Disorder · AustraliaTalk · An Introduction to Narcissism: The map is not the territory · AustraliaUploading a Talk · AustraliaPrivacy Policy · AustraliaAbout Calabash · AustraliaCalabash · New ZealandCalabash Articles · New ZealandCalabash Partners · New ZealandCalabash Contributors · New ZealandCalabash Speakers · New ZealandCalabash Talks · New ZealandCalabash Sign up · New ZealandCalabash Sign in · New ZealandNeurodiversity CPD talks · New ZealandClinical Issues CPD talks · New ZealandCouples CPD talks · New ZealandArticle · Why home treatment for dizziness is not a good idea · New ZealandArticle · SAPC Dialogues: Introduction to the Dialogues · New ZealandArticle · Note Taking in a Hospital Setting · New ZealandAustralia CPD talks · New Zealand CPD talks · New ZealandSpeech therapy CPD talks · New ZealandTalk · Listening and Language Development Driven by Play in 0-3 Years Old · New ZealandTalk · Psycho-oncology: Psychological aspects of cancer & its treatment · New ZealandTalk · Couples Counselling: An essential introductory map · New ZealandPrivacy Policy · New ZealandAbout Partners · New ZealandUploading an Article · New ZealandCalabash · United KingdomCalabash Articles · United KingdomCalabash Partners · United KingdomCalabash Contributors · United KingdomCalabash Speakers · United KingdomCalabash Talks · United KingdomCalabash Sign up · United KingdomCalabash Sign in · United KingdomCognitive Behavioural Therapy CPD talks · United KingdomMood Disorders CPD talks · United KingdomImago Relationship Therapy CPD talks · United KingdomArticle · Understanding sensory processing disorder · United KingdomArticle · Therapist Accountability in Work with Children · United KingdomArticle · An Intro to Marketing for Healthcare Professionals · United KingdomNeuroanatomy CPD talks · United KingdomParenting CPD talks · United KingdomOccupational therapy CPD talks · United KingdomTalk · CBT with Children & Adolescents: Depression · United KingdomTalk · CBT with Children and Adolescents: Generalized Anxiety Disorder · United KingdomTalk · Combined Child-Parent Model of Assessment & Therapeutic Communication · United KingdomAbout Calabash · United KingdomUploading an Article · United KingdomPrivacy Policy · United KingdomCalabash · United StatesCalabash Articles · United StatesCalabash Partners · United StatesCalabash Contributors · United StatesCalabash Speakers · United StatesCalabash Talks · United StatesCalabash Sign up · United StatesCalabash Sign in · United StatesAllied Health Professionals CPD talks · United StatesImago Relationship Therapy CPD talks · United StatesCognitive Behavioural Therapy CPD talks · United StatesArticle · Decolonising Psychology? · United StatesArticle · Insights into Adlerian Theory and Therapy · United StatesArticle · Tips to ensure neuroplastic changes in therapy · United StatesCreative Ability CPD talks · United StatesCanada CPD talks · United States CPD talks · United StatesTalk · Time-Limited Psychodynamic Psychotherapy · United StatesTalk · Psycho-oncology: Psychological aspects of cancer & its treatment · United StatesTalk · Confidentiality in Schools · United StatesAbout Partners · United StatesHow It Works · United StatesFrequently Asked Questions · United StatesCalabash · CanadaCalabash Articles · CanadaCalabash Partners · CanadaCalabash Contributors · CanadaCalabash Speakers · CanadaCalabash Talks · CanadaCalabash Sign up · CanadaCalabash Sign in · CanadaNeuro CPD talks · CanadaCognitive Behavioural Therapy CPD talks · CanadaAllied Health Professionals CPD talks · CanadaArticle · What is Emotion-Focused Couple's Therapy (EFT)? · CanadaArticle · Common Medications for Mood Stabilization · CanadaArticle · The Development of Masculinity in Ulwaluko kwa Xhosa · Canada CPD talks · CanadaSports Psychology CPD talks · CanadaAutism CPD talks · CanadaTalk · Working Therapeutically with Infants, Young Children & their Parents · CanadaTalk · CBT with Children and Adolescents: Generalized Anxiety Disorder · CanadaTalk · DIR: Floortime- an overview · CanadaAbout Calabash · CanadaAbout Partners · CanadaTerms of Use · Canada
Psychologist in Sydney